In my experience, 9 out of 10 people would say that dehydration is the main cause of various issues. Especially a lack of performance. I used to believe the same thing. However, is that really the case?
While numerous studies have made a compelling argument for dehydration as a significant factor, I found that many of these studies were not adequately designed. Specifically, very few were conducted under outdoor simulated conditions where the wind would naturally cool the participants. Additionally, it is quite challenging to blind the subjects to their hydration status in most hydration studies since they are always aware of how much they drink.
Therefore, my team and I decided to investigate this matter further. We designed a study in which we deliberately dehydrated the participants to 3% of their body weight and then rehydrated them using an intravenous saline solution in a blinded manner. Prior to a 25 km time trial in hot conditions (with a 35 km/h wind), the participants were at 0% (fully rehydrated), 2%, or 3% dehydration levels.
So, what do you think happened?
The surprising result was... nothing!
It turns out that hydration levels did not affect performance. Or physiology for that matter. Regardless of their level of dehydration, the participants performed equally. To be honest, we were shocked by these results. We had expected that even a 3% level of dehydration would have an impact, but it didn't. Although rectal temperature showed a slight statistical increase, it was not a meaningful one.
Upon delving deeper into the data to understand why, we discovered that the body possesses remarkable mechanisms for fluid redistribution to meet its requirements. The guys at Fast Talk Labs did a really nice breakdown of the study on a recent podcast if you want to dive further into it.
Reflecting on a recent mountain biking adventure I had with Athletica ambassador Marjaana Rakai, we found ourselves with only one bottle of water each for a ride that ended up lasting four hours due to getting lost. We were both thirsty and had dry mouths. If water had been available, we certainly would have drunk more. However, we both managed just fine and performed well.
This anecdote conveys the practical message of this post: use your thirst as an indicator of your hydration status. If you feel thirsty, then drink. It is important to recognize that our bodies have built-in mechanisms to protect us, and there has never been a documented case of death caused by dehydration in sports. On the contrary, there have been several deaths resulting from over-drinking in long distance events.
The issue is called hyponatremia. I'll explain more next week and how you can avoid it.
Until then, happy training,
Paul
Paul Laursen, PhD
Smarter training starts here. Athletica’s newsletters deliver science-backed insights, expert tips, and AI-powered training updates for endurance athletes of all levels. Catch up on past editions and subscribe to stay ahead in your training journey.
Hello June has felt like a month where everything we talk about came to life. Iris Nafshi, a researcher who studied moms training for Ironman while raising kids and finishing a PhD. A virtual 5K that pulled in athletes from all corners of the globe on the same weekend. A blog MJ wrote a couple years ago about why "balance" is a myth, and why MJ still stands by every word. Three different things. Same idea underneath: big goals are possible in a full life. They just require a different kind of...
Dear Reader, I remember learning about energy systems in school. Professor Paul Gastin's diagram was the gold standard: a clean picture of how much each system contributed depending on effort duration. You've probably seen similar. ATP-PCr, Glycolysis/lactic, Aerobic; each with its lane, each with its moment. Gastin (2001)'s classic energy system interaction model for maximal exercise. Then I watched a film that added the piece Gastin hadn't for me. That these systems are never one or the...
Hello Reader, Sebastian Sawe ran 1:59:30 in London last weekend. Three men finished under the previous world record for the marathon. Coaches and media publicly credited 100–120 g/hr of carbohydrate. The running internet promptly lost its mind. So on the Athlete’s Compass Podcast this week, Paul Warloski and I took the question head-on: should you be eating like Sawe? Short answer: no. But the longer answer is more interesting. And it points somewhere the sports nutrition field hasn’t quite...